I’ve spent
a fair amount of time in the last two weeks wondering why I’ve been unable to
write a blog post. I’ve started two – the first a reflection on the lack of out
gay bishops in the C of E and the second on the ethics of ‘outing’ people – and been unable to finish them.
It’s only
this evening that I’ve figured out what’s going on.
I’ve
realized I’ve been caught up in a matrix of frustration and pain. I know. That's sounds a bit over the top. And maybe it is. But this ‘matrix’
has elements of the personal and the corporate, and it’s only now that Advent
has arrived that I can begin to articulate their meaning.
Firstly,
the personal. My health woes have been documented (‘over-documented’?) on this
blog. Truth is, things are ok and I have very little to complain about most of
the time. But I do find the gastro-related pain a bit wearing. I’m eating some
food and I’m being very careful, but basically everything I’m eating is causing
pain. I have access to decent pain relief, but that pain relief itself has
side-effects. When all of this is figured into a world marked by slowly moving
NHS gears and a(n over-)busy life it can all get a bit frustrating. I can be a
right bloody grump. It can lead to a pretty jaded reading of reality. I apologise to anyone who's had to put up with that recently!
But these
personal factors have been caught up in my frustration with more corporate
matters to do with ‘The Church’. (I put those words in ‘scare’ quotes to
indicate my acknowledgement that to blame the ‘whole’ church is slightly
absurd.) Ultimately, I get frustrated that the church isn't quite as 'sorted' as many of us would like it to be. I think of my mate Lucy Gorman’s
recent experience of a church in Hull – a church she grew up in – that felt it
could not stick a poster advertising Hull’s LGBT Fellowship on the church
noticeboard. From that ‘detail’ I then think of the appalling treatment of LGBT
people in various parts of the world and how the leadership of the C of E seemingly won’t
stand up and speak out about the tragic human cost. I also think of the list
of trans men and women that was read out at last week’s Trans Day of Remembrance event in Manchester
– a list of over 250 people killed for being trans in the past year – and how far skewed readings of faith beliefs might have been a motivating factor in murder
and its attempted justification. And so on…
I know I am
tired and frustrated and in pain and often a grump because of it. I know that
in so many ways the world seems to be moving forward and that I, like so many,
live a life of extreme privilege. And I know, only too well, that for people of
faith the feeling of ‘why can’t the institution be shaped according to my
beliefs’ is a common (and faintly ridiculous) one.
To be in
the season of Advent is helpful, however. If we can allow ourselves to resist –
however feebly – the tinsel and mammon-fest that December has become, Advent
offers a space for pause, reflection and waiting in anticipation. It is a kind
of matrix of hope.
I choose
the word ‘matrix’ deliberately. In terms of the Latin root, ‘matrix’ is a term
of fecundity – a word for a body capable of reproduction. This can have
oppressive implications (e.g., of a body used for breeding), but I want to
claim ‘matrix’ as a positive - as a place of
possibility; as a place of darkness, not in a negative sense, but as a place of
warmth, of incubation and of new life.
We are
always in cultural and discursive matrixes, and
Advent is a point of origin – of news and beginnings and the rehearsal of
beginnings. Advent might be seen as gesturing towards what Judith Butler calls
a structure of relations that makes individual acts
of will possible, providing their “enabling cultural condition”.
To
put it simply, Advent is a womb, a point of origin. It offers the possibility
of good news – of good news that might be anticipated, but cannot yet be seen
or known.
I
feel the positive power of that in my personal life. But I sense also its truth in the
corporate struggles for new life, justice and good news that are going on in
the wider church. To place current birth-pangs in a context of Advent isn’t (it
seems to me) to justify all the crap. But it offers the promise that the crap
might be part of a hope-filled story.